Alternative songwriter • guitarist • vocalist

In your experience, do the best-written melodies seem to be generated by an instrument or separate from one?
Separate! Always separate!
I find that any time I venture to write a tune (whole or in part) while staring down at an instrument all I see are notes and scales that I have seen before. Confronted with that — even just the muscle memory of playing chords — I find that I never get too far. At best, anything I’d write with a guitar in my hands or at a piano ends up turning out as derivative as I would fear.
Instead I prefer to collect melodies in a sort of undisciplined way. For some reason or another, something might pop into my head walking down the street (this is my favorite sort), in the shower, during a film, etc. If it seems to have merit then I find it’s not hard to remember it and so I sort of set aside all of these melodies for a rainy day. Then, when I feel like writing something — e.g. maybe I come up with a lyric or maybe even a title I like — there’s a slew of melodies in the back of my mind that I plow through to try to find one that seems like a best fit. Sort of like picking out the right suit for the right occasion.
Do more songs come from sitting down and working out your craft or from a flash of inspiration?
I generally don’t ‘try’ to force myself into writing anymore. At least I haven’t for a long while. And I don’t really ask myself where the ideas (melodies/lyrics/dynamics) come from. I couldn’t care less, to be honest. It’s enough for me to know that I hear music and enjoy making art and that that music is just sort of there, like an imaginary stuffed elephant best friend is to a toddler.
Actually, I was watching the FX series ‘Wilfred’ the other day and I couldn’t help but thinking that I identified with the character in a kind of uncanny way. The talking dog thing is a pretty good metaphor (or is it allegory? — I can never get that right) for that kind of internal, creative voice. Whether or not you choose to interpret that voice constructively or destructively… that’s on you, I suppose.
As for craft? For me that’s another side of the equation entirely. Inspiration comes and goes. Craft, to me, is what I talked about before when I was like, “Hmmm…how do I marry these lyrical concepts to this beat I have in mind and with whatever melody I have in the kitty…” Putting that all together feels like craft to me. It’s applying a million little lessons you’ve learned over the course of trying to write every piece of music you’ve ever tried to write, or more often, heard and loved and dissected. Whether you’re building a chair or cobbling together a pop song, I think craft is about the application of knowledge to art.
How autobiographical are your songs?
Meh.
I’m not sure that I am too interested in autobiography. At the same time, I only really can make good music out of things which I feel passionate… so I find that I inherently write ‘what I know’. So I guess I feel like the songs — the ones I finish and bother to perform — are personal, but personal to me without having real narratives. Narratives kind of bore me; which isn’t to say that I don’t think narrative songwriting is bad, but it’s just not my jones I guess.
Every so often I will look back over a lyric sheet or hear a tune that’s been recorded by one of the bands I’ve been in and I’ve written for, and think “Holy f**k, I was saying [x] and being very deliberate about it, wasn’t I?” But that stuff only ever seems to really hit me in hindsight. Because while I’m in the trenches trying to finish a song it’s all about a “whatever it takes” mentality to finish it. Some things are done in haste and others in a kind of fog of war/inspiration and there’s no time to think or worry about why. Because I hate having unfinished s**t; I just want the song in question to be done. Then I can move onto the next song and want that song to be done.
Where did you come up with the idea for your featured song?
This song is called “Ladies & Gentlemen” and it was the first song I wrote on purpose for my new band, Cold Blood Club.
I wanted a tune for my friends Kendra and Brad to sing together so they would be able to hit the ground running as the two frontpersons of the new group. So, the thinking was, “OK, let’s make sure it’s (a) kinda big so they can get really excited to sing it, (b) let’s have it be explicitly about New York which is where we all live and shared our time together as friends, (c) make it not suck, and (d) make sure it’s in a key so that they can both sing it comfortably in opposing octaves. Later, as the rest of the band came on board, they helped shape the dynamic and sharpen things (especially in the bridge). Additionally, our friend Jason (Finkel) came on board as producer and you can really credit him with adding a lot of sizzle to the choruses. Sonically, he’s a savant.
Anyways, it’s my favorite song I’ve had the pleasure of recording in some time and I am excited to send it along to the internets, and by extension, the world.
Listen to the featured song!
Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.
Artist web site