November 9, 2011

Interview: Probyn Gregory

Pop songwriter • multi-instrumentalist

What sort of kid were you?

Oldest of 6, I sorta had to keep it together, but I was painfully shy and a real nature bug, which wrought the genesis for my quasi-pantheism today. Autumn as portent of winter brought me to tears so often that it became an embarrassment. HIGHLY nostalgic and romantic until I burnt that circuit out by overuse by adolescence. Reading and music saved my psychic a**. The golden rule was easily visible in action to me from a young age. In my picture here, I am chasing my now-lost youth.

Do you feel that melody is as important as it once was?

Depends on what avenue you’re looking at. While I deride the ascendency of non-melodic movements in popular music like rap, hip hop and what passes for modern R&B, much good melody is being championed by modern composers over many ethnicities. The entire concept of melody seems to be morphing away from the populist everybody-singing-around-the-parlor-piano to a focus on fixed recordings and specific timbres as key to the song instead of being mere production choices, as once they were. Personally, I feel this can lead to laziness in creating a melody that can stand alone apart from these conceits. I predict that what will continue to stand the test of time is what people themselves can sing or whistle or play themselves on a given instrument, e.g. the melody alone– no lyrics, no particular sound. All that is icing– the core is the mere notes/rhythm.

When you are working on a song, how do you generate melodic ideas? Do you play chords on a piano?

Apart from the very best fertile ground (ideas vouchsafed from a dream or heard in my head while performing other tasks, which can and has included listening to other music radically different from the ideas I then heard), I play chords on whatever is the instrument of choice at the moment — generally piano or guitar. As many others have attested, the sound and feel of the instrument can itself lead to certain note choices. My true test of a harmonic idea is whether or not it can stand alone with just a bass line below it– if the auditor can fill in some of the missing notes of the implied chord him or herself. Every once in a great while I will begin with words, which dictate a certain rhythm and sometimes suggest an architecture of a melody– whether it goes up or down to fit the words best.

Tell me about the track that’s featured.

“I Send Up My Prayer” was a small dream idea that I honed staring out the window on the bus to work in 1986. I had gotten sick of hearing music in my head and not knowing what the chords were, so learned to decipher those over the past few years. When I did sit down to play what I had constructed in my head, the music came quickly (this was absolutely a keyboard song, with dense close voicings) and it can work with just melody and bass, which is how I do the first verse when I perform it. The words are still not quite to my liking despite months of dickering. This version was recorded in 2010 by a Dutch group, the Nick Vernier Band, who asked me to sing the lead vocal.

Listen to the featured song!

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

Purchase Sessions by Nick Vernier Band here!

Artist web site